Secure online therapy across Idaho & California

In crisis? Call or text 988, any time.

GuideChristian counseling, biblical counseling and therapy: what is the difference?

Biblical counseling is guidance from Scripture, usually offered through a church. Pastoral counseling is care from a member of the clergy. Therapy with a Christian therapist is mental health care from a clinician regulated by the state, who brings faith into the work when you ask for it.

Three kinds of help that share a name

Biblical counseling

Usually offered through a church by a pastor or a trained church member. Scripture is the main guide. It is discipleship and spiritual care, and those who offer it are generally not licensed by the state to treat mental health conditions.

Pastoral counseling

Care from a pastor, priest or chaplain, often short term, around faith, grief, marriage or a hard decision. Some pastoral counselors also have clinical training, and some do not.

Therapy with a Christian therapist

Mental health care from a clinician with a graduate degree who is licensed or registered by the state and bound by its confidentiality laws and professional ethics. The therapist shares or understands your faith, and it becomes part of the work to the degree you want.

How to choose

  • For a spiritual question, such as doubt, calling or how to pray through a hard season, a pastor or biblical counselor may be the right person.
  • For trauma, panic, obsessive thoughts, depression or anything that is disrupting daily life, see a clinician. You can ask for one who respects your faith.
  • Many people use both. A pastor and a therapist do different work, and they are not in competition.

Questions worth asking

  • Are you licensed or registered by the state, and where can I verify that?
  • How do you bring faith into sessions, and what if I would prefer that you did not?
  • What happens to what I tell you? Who else hears it?

At Selah & Stone Collective

Madeline offers therapy, not biblical or pastoral counseling. The practice is rooted in the Christian faith, and prayer, Scripture and spiritual questions can be part of sessions for clients who want that. Clients of any faith, or none, receive the same care. More on how faith fits into therapy.

Last updated November 22, 2026. This guide is general information from Selah & Stone Collective. It is not medical advice and does not replace care from a professional who knows your situation.

More guides

Common questions

Quick answers

See all questions
Is a Christian counselor the same as a therapist?

Not always. The words Christian counselor can describe a church-based biblical counselor or a state-regulated therapist who is a Christian. Ask whether the person is licensed or registered by the state.

Do I have to be a Christian to see a Christian therapist?

No. A therapist follows the client’s lead. At Selah & Stone Collective, faith is part of therapy only if you want it, and only as much as you want.

Can I see a pastor and a therapist at the same time?

Yes. Many people do. A pastor offers spiritual care and a therapist offers mental health care, and the two can work alongside each other.

You don’t have to have it all figured out to begin.

Start with a free, no-pressure conversation. Tell Madeline a little about what’s going on, and she’ll help you find the next step.

Online sessions for clients in Idaho and California. In crisis? Call or text 988.

Free consultation Call